Myths of Filing a Claim for Property Damage: Setting the Record Straight

December 2, 2024

When it comes to property damage, whether it's from a storm, an accident, or another unfortunate incident, filing a claim with your insurance company can be a stressful and confusing process. One of the biggest hurdles is sorting through the myths and misconceptions about how insurance companies handle property damage claims. Many people worry that filing a claim might lead to rate hikes, dropped coverage, or other negative consequences, especially if the claim is not their fault.

Let's take a look at some common myths surrounding property damage claims and debunk them with the facts.

Myth 1: Filing a Claim Will Automatically Increase My Insurance Rates

One of the most common fears is that filing a claim for property damage will result in higher insurance premiums. However, this is not necessarily true, especially when the claim is non-fault.

The Fact: If you are not at fault in an incident (e.g., another driver hits your car, or your home is damaged by a neighbor’s tree), insurance companies by law cannot increase your rates or drop you for filing a claim. This protection is specifically designed to shield policyholders from being penalized for events beyond their control. Your insurance company is legally required to honor your policy without penalizing you for incidents that were not your fault.

Myth 2: My Insurance Company Will Drop Me if I File a Claim

Many people believe that their insurance provider will drop them after filing a claim, particularly if it's for a significant amount. While it’s true that certain types of claims, like frequent or fraudulent claims, could put your policy in jeopardy, a single, legitimate non-fault claim should not be a reason for cancellation.

The Fact: As long as you maintain your payments and comply with your policy terms, your insurance company cannot drop you simply because you file a claim. This protection extends to claims that are not your fault. However, if you have multiple claims within a short time frame, even if they're not your fault, this could be flagged by the insurer as a higher risk––but that’s a different situation entirely.

Myth 3: My Insurance Claim Will Be Denied if I Don’t Have Detailed Documentation

It's easy to assume that without perfect documentation, your insurance claim will be automatically denied. While having detailed records of the incident will certainly help your case, though, the idea that you need exhaustive documentation to get your claim approved is a myth.

The Fact: It's always best to provide as much documentation as possible, including photos, receipts, and any police or incident reports, but insurance companies typically will not deny a claim solely because you don't have every single detail documented. If your property damage is legitimate and within the coverage terms of your policy, the insurance company is likely to approve your claim, even if the documentation isn’t exhaustive.

Myth 4: My Claim Will Take Forever to Process

Another common myth is that it’s not worth filing a claim because insurance companies drag their feet when processing claims, leaving homeowners or policyholders in the dark for weeks or even months.  

The Fact: The key to faster processing is ensuring you file a complete claim with as much information as possible and respond promptly to any additional requests from your insurer. While some claims can take time depending on the complexity of the situation, the insurance company has an obligation to adjust your claim promptly and fairly by law. 

Myth 5: If I File a Property Damage Claim, My Deductible Will Always Be High

You may worry that your deductible will be a barrier to filing a property damage claim. However, your deductible only applies if the damage you’re filing for is covered and if the total cost of repairs exceeds that amount.

The Fact: While you may have a deductible that you’ll need to pay when you file a claim, this doesn’t necessarily mean you should avoid filing a claim altogether. If the damage exceeds your deductible, it’s worth filing a claim to get the repair costs covered by your insurance. Additionally, if the damage is extensive and clearly beyond your deductible, it’s often better to file and cover the deductible rather than paying for repairs entirely out of pocket.

Understanding the truth behind these property insurance myths can make a significant difference in how you handle a property damage claim. Filing a claim for property damage should not automatically increase your rates or result in dropped coverage, especially if the incident was not your fault. Remember that your insurance is there to protect you, and it’s important to use it when needed to avoid paying for damages out of pocket.

If you're ever uncertain about the claims process or your rights as a policyholder, don't hesitate to reach out to your insurance provider for clarification. Knowing the facts will help you navigate the process with confidence and ensure you get the coverage and support you deserve.

If you need assistance or have questions about property damage claims, feel free to contact us. We're here to help guide you through the process and ensure your peace of mind.

Read More News

Read This
Logo of ATE

Understanding Homeowners Insurance: What You Need to Know

Read This
Logo of ATE

Make Hurricane Preparedness Your New Year’s Resolution!

Read This

knowledge and experience you can rely on

Talk to Us Today

Need experienced local attorneys to help you get compensation for a personal injury case, handle a homeowners insurance claim, or settle an estate? Reach out to Anderson Traylor Edwards in Hammond, Louisiana today.

Schedule Free Consultation